I'm a business consultant who also provides training and education who loves to talk about business & entrepreneurship, education, and finance. Subscribe to my newsletter.
“I Can’t Afford to Pay Better” — The Hidden Cost of Underpaying Your Team
|
Hi Reader, “I can’t afford to pay better.” That may be one of the most expensive assumptions a business can make. When margins feel tight and labor costs continue to rise, holding the line on wages can feel like the responsible decision. But in many cases, underpaying your team costs far more than paying competitively. In the LBM industry, experienced employees carry enormous operational knowledge. They understand product applications, contractor expectations, yard logistics, and the countless small decisions that keep a job running smoothly. That expertise isn’t easy to replace. When those employees leave for slightly better pay somewhere else, the cost isn’t just their replacement wage. It’s the disruption that follows. I worked with a dealer whose yard manager struggled to keep workers because a nearby competitor consistently paid a little more. Every few months, another employee left. Each departure started the same cycle. Hiring. Deliveries slowed. The company believed it was controlling payroll costs. In reality, it was paying for turnover again and again. The Real Cost Low wages create hidden costs that quietly drain performance. When compensation falls below market levels, businesses begin to experience: • Higher turnover and constant hiring cycles These costs rarely show up neatly on a single report. But they absolutely show up in your margins, productivity, and customer experience. The Fix Pay strategy should be viewed as an operational investment, not simply a labor expense. Strong dealers take a more strategic approach. Benchmark wages regularly: Understand what competitors and related trades are paying in your market. Invest in skilled employees: Experienced team members work faster, make fewer mistakes, and deliver better customer service. Look for operational inefficiencies: Pricing issues, weak processes, or outdated policies often hide the real sources of margin pressure. Reward performance: Compensation structures that recognize reliability, productivity, and expertise help retain your best people. When compensation aligns with market expectations, retention improves, productivity rises, and the entire operation becomes more stable. The Bottom Line If you truly can’t afford to pay competitive wages, the real question may be why. Operational inefficiencies, weak pricing discipline, or outdated processes are often the real culprits—not payroll. The strongest LBM businesses understand that investing in the right people is one of the most reliable ways to improve service, efficiency, and long-term profitability. Best regards, Emily Emily Overson Consulting |
Emily Overson Consulting
I'm a business consultant who also provides training and education who loves to talk about business & entrepreneurship, education, and finance. Subscribe to my newsletter.
Hi Reader, “We have the software.” For many businesses, that statement creates a false sense of progress. The ERP has been purchased.The POS system is installed.The implementation is complete. So leadership assumes the problem is solved. But months later, nothing really changes. Inventory errors continue.Reports are still being built manually.Salespeople are writing notes in notebooks.Margin tracking still lives in Excel. The software exists. The adoption doesn’t. I worked with an LBM dealer...
Hi Reader, “They should just be grateful.” Sometimes it sounds a little different: “I pay them well. That should be enough.” And on the surface, that feels reasonable. Compensation is one of the biggest investments any business makes in its people. But many leaders eventually discover something important: Paychecks attract employees.Recognition is what keeps them engaged. In the LBM industry—where work is demanding, deadlines are tight, and teams operate under constant pressure—feeling valued...
Hi Reader, “I’ll just do it myself.” That phrase has burned out more leaders than most businesses realize. It usually starts with good intentions. A delivery goes wrong.A customer is upset.A deadline is tight. And in the moment, the fastest solution is for the leader to step in and fix the problem personally. Occasionally, that’s necessary. But when it becomes the default response, something dangerous starts happening: The team stops solving problems on their own. Over time, the operation...